NLENFor installers
All items

WaterAccu vs smart switch: a comparison

Do you have solar panels? An affordable way to make better use of your solar energy is by using an electric water heater with smart control. Wondering what the extra benefits of the Nymo are? In this blog, we explain the differences between the two systems and present the results of an analysis we carried out to see exactly how much difference there is in savings between the two.

Why choose an electric water heater with smart control?

Solar panels are a brilliant way to drive the energy transition and ensure that households can use more clean energy. The Netherlands ranks first in the EU for solar panels per capita, and almost 1/3 of households have solar panels on their roof!

The problem, however, is that there is a mismatch between household energy consumption and solar energy production. Generally, households use the most energy in the morning and evening, while sunshine peaks between 12:00 and 15:00. As a result, only 30-40% of the solar generation is used within the household, and the rest is fed back to the grid. A waste!

For households, this wasn't a big problem yet due to the net metering (salderingsregeling). However, this scheme will be abolished at the end of 2026, making solar panels much less profitable. Furthermore, energy companies have introduced monthly feed-in charges for feeding back solar energy.

What is the solution? Use more of your own solar generation! If you use more solar energy (called your "self-consumption"), you pay fewer feed-in charges and need less electricity from the grid. One way to do this is by running an electric water heater on surplus solar energy and using the hot tap water later when needed. Here, we compare two solutions to achieve this: a "smart switch" and the WaterAccu from Solyx Energy.

What is a smart switch? And how does it work?

A smart switch is an addition to your socket, which you can then plug other devices into. Examples include the HomeWizard Energy Socket and the EcoSwitch Pi from Ecosoft. These smart switches are intended to map your device's consumption. But they also offer extra functions, including the ability to turn devices on when surplus solar energy is available—hence a "smart switch". This function can be used to control an electric water heater, where the heating element is switched on as soon as a certain threshold for surplus solar energy is reached.

What is the WaterAccu? And how does it compare to the smart switch?

The WaterAccu works differently from a smart switch. The big difference: a switch simply turns on or off. So the electric water heater is either on at full power or off. The WaterAccu varies the power to the electric water heater. So it's not just on or off; exactly the amount of surplus solar energy is sent to the electric water heater. The downside: the WaterAccu has a higher purchase price than a smart switch. 

Due to variations in cloud cover and consumption throughout the day, solar generation is different at every moment. Ideally, you want your electric water heater to be heated purely and solely by solar energy, and this is exactly what the WaterAccu does. If solar generation drops, the WaterAccu will adjust the power supply. The graphs below show an example of this over 24 hours.

Solyx Energy_WaterAccu_Nymo_WaterAccu_graph

Explanation of the top graph:

  • The orange line shows the total solar generation.
  • The blue line shows the household consumption.
  • The green area shows the unused solar energy, and this is exactly the amount the WaterAccu will utilise.
  • The Nymo sends exactly the amount of unused power to the electric water heater.

Explanation of the bottom graph:

  • Grid input, or the use of electricity from the grid, occurs as soon as no solar energy is being generated but household appliances are on.
  • All solar energy is utilised, and there is no feeding back to the grid!

A smart switch uses less solar energy and increases electricity consumption from the grid

Solyx Energy_WaterAccu_Nymo_Smart Switch_graph

Above, it is clearly visible that around 10:45 the cut-in threshold of the smart switch is reached and the electric water heater is turned on.

These differences naturally lead to a difference in savings. To find out exactly how much, the two scenarios were modelled over an entire year.

Explanation of the top graph:

  • The orange line again shows the total solar generation.
  • The blue line shows the household consumption.
  • The purple line shows that around 10:45 the cut-in threshold of the smart switch is reached, and the electric water heater is turned on (on at full power).
  • The green area shows the amount of unused solar energy that the smart switch will utilise.
  • The yellow area shows the solar energy that is still fed back to the grid.

Quite a lot of surplus solar energy is used on this day. But due to the simple on/off function, it is not as accurate as the WaterAccu; if there is a dip in solar energy availability, extra grid power is even used to power the electric water heater.

Explanation of the bottom graph:

  • Grid input, or the use of electricity from the grid, occurs as soon as no solar energy is being generated but household appliances are on.
  • Furthermore, feeding back to the grid still occurs when the available surplus solar energy is not used.
  • Additionally, extra grid power is used during dips in solar generation.

Conclusion: The WaterAccu saves almost 2x as much as a smart switch

The study assumed a baseline situation where the household initially heats tap water with a combi boiler.

    • The saving with a WaterAccu is about 362 euros per year
    • The saving with a smart switch is about 151 euros per year

The conclusions:

  • Both solutions provide savings, so they are a good step forward!
  • The saving with the WaterAccu is more than twice as large as the saving with the smart switch.
  • For this study, the most ideal threshold value was used, based on annual data. It is unlikely that a household would be able to choose this value just as favourably – unless it is actively changed throughout the year based on predicted weather conditions. This is despite the fact that this cut-in threshold is also the parameter with the greatest effect on savings.
  • Despite the higher investment costs of the WaterAccu compared to a smart switch, the household will save significantly more money with the WaterAccu after 3 years. Additionally, the WaterAccu has extra smart functions such as automatic legionella protection, so no hassle or intervention is needed after installation.
  • Feed-in charges have not been taken into account, which will make the WaterAccu's savings even greater.
  • Heating with an electric water heater without smart functions is relatively expensive. If an electric water heater is already present, buying the WaterAccu is a real no-brainer, as it pays for itself in just over 1 year!

Discussion of the model

Here we discuss in more detail how the analysis was carried out and what assumptions were made.

A typical household of 4 people was used as the basis for this analysis. The household has a 200 l electric water heater, with 16 solar panels of 6.4 kWp. Using realistic solar radiation and household energy consumption data, three "standard" days were generated. A summer day (sunny), a winter day (low-sun) and an autumn/spring day (cloudy). These were extrapolated over a year.

Model assumptions:

  • No net metering – this ends from 2027.
  • No feed-in charges – these will also be reviewed in a few years, so they have been left out of consideration.
  • Smart switch activation is constant throughout the year (set at 1.2kW) – this value was chosen to be favourable for the smart switch. It is important to note that households choosing a cut-in cannot determine the ideal value so accurately.
  • Once the smart switch turns the electric water heater on, it stays on until the tank is fully heated.
  • The household uses an average amount of hot water for which the electric water heater must be reheated every day.

As a reference, a simple "dumb" electric water heater was also modelled, which turns on automatically when hot water is used. It was assumed this was in the morning and evening. The results were also compared with a traditional setup where tap water is heated with a combi boiler, which works according to the same logic as the simple electric water heater.

Read more?!

What will it save you?

Enter your panels and household details to see your savings and payback period.

Calculate your savings